Apr 18, 2010

The Remains of the Day

If you recall, I was not impressed by Ishiguro's When We Were Orphans.  I decided to give him another try and recently read The Remains of the Day.  It's a character study of Stevens, an English butler in the mid-1950s.  His previous employer dead, he now works for an American who bought Darlington Hall, the house Stevens ran for many years. 

Stevens takes an opportunity to visit former co-worker Mrs. Benn née Miss Kenton.  With permission, he borrows Mr. Farraday's car and goes on a road trip through Devon and Cornwall.  As happens in all good road trips, Stevens encounters some interesting people and beautiful scenery, stumbles into some comic misadventures, and has plenty of time to reflect on his life.

Through the stories of the past woven into the experiences of the present, we learn that Miss Kenton served as a foil to Stevens over the years they served Lord Darlington.  Stevens, preoccupied with propriety and duty, accepted his employer's word as law; in doing so, he gave up some of his humanity and supported some questionable decisions.  Miss Kenton was more compassionate beneath her similarly high professional standards.  Because of their differences, there are many misunderstandings between Miss Kenton and Stevens, and she ultimately leaves Lord Darlington's employ to marry.  Stevens' road trip is, in part, a trip to see if Mrs. Benn would like to return as housekeeper to Darlington Hall due to the unhappiness with her marriage she expressed to Stevens in a letter.

It's hard not to include spoilers in these posts.  I will say that I found the ending of the book very poignant and definitely recommend The Remains of the Day.  Stevens isn't always a sympathetic character, but by the end Ishiguro leads the reader to an understanding of Stevens' motivations and Stevens to an understanding of his own mistakes.  The ending is surprisingly hopeful, even if there is an undercurrent of melancholy.  In some ways, it reminds me of the ending to The Sun Also Rises.  While Hemingway's book ends with regret, Ishiguro's takes half a step back from the "Isn't it pretty to think so?" lament and substitutes the truth that the past doesn't have to determine the future.

Labels: , , ,

Feb 8, 2010

When We Were Orphans

I finished reading Kazuo Ishiguro's When We Were Orphans last night.  It was a disappointment.

About 1/3 of the way through, my friend Hilary, who had recommended I read some Ishiguro, noted that it was her least favorite of his books.  She probably had told me that before I bought it at Half Price Books, but it was too late by the time she told me the second time.

Part of the problem may be that I don't know enough about Shanghai in the 1920s-1930s, the opium trade, or the clashes between the Japanese and Chinese.  The rest of the problem is that I find Christopher Banks unbelievable.  The main character is allegedly a "renowned London detective," yet he seems lacking in self-awareness and intuition, particularly as the book builds to a climax.  He is the Michael Scott of detectives---socially awkward without fully realizing it, arrogant if well-meaning, and selfishly insistent on his own childish way. 

This is established early in the book, as he reflects on an upcoming event to be attended by the rich and important personages of the day: "I was aware, of course, that this particular evening would be on a different level from anything I had ever attended at university; that I might well, moreover, encounter points of custom as yet unfamiliar with me.  But I felt sure I would, with my usual vigilance, negotiate any such difficulties, and in general acquit myself well."  (page 12, Vintage paperback edition)  Yet, when he struggles socially during the evening, he can't accept that the fault is more than marginally his own, and decides he has "every right to despise the people around [him]...they were for the most part greedy and self-seeking, lacking any idealism or sense of public duty." (page 14)

On one hand, it's a beautifully written book and Ishiguro does a fine job painting a picture of a particular type of person.  It's understandable that a child raised by expatriates, orphaned at a young age, and sent to live in his "native" but completely unfamiliar country would have trouble fitting in and be hampered by self-absorption.  His self-importance is explained by his idealism and his professional triumphs.  The issue I have is that I can't quite understand how he could be a successful detective when so hobbled by his seeming inability to see things from other points of view.  When things don't go his way, his reaction is to lash out at the people around him--even those trying to help him in the endeavor of the moment--and assert that he knows better.

Of course, I could be just as misled as Christopher, insisting the character makes no sense when I'm too blind to see a deeper truth.

Labels: ,